Grindelwald heavily but unclearly implies that Credence is Dumbledore’s brother. Their lifeboat sailed to safety… Was Grindelwald telling the truth? As for why no one else knew about it: Dumbledore didn't tell anyone, and this would have been such a short-lived fling that, in the drama surrounding the deaths of his mother and sister, no one would have paid too much attention to a witch passing through. Credence is the only entity alive who can kill Dumbledore "Entity" is a strange choice of words here. The prophecy about Credence/Aurelius describes him as "a son cruelly banished," which perfectly fits with a child sent back to America after Dumbledore didn't want him. Albus Dumbledore's Sister Ariana May Have Been An Obscurial. Theory: I think Credence is Ariana Dumbledore's son, and Albus Dumbledore's nephew, and not his brother. Related: Fantastic Beasts: Explaining The Harry Potter Canon Plot Holes. The Dumbledore-Son theory also makes The Crimes of Grindelwald's LeStrange bait-and-switch a whole lot more satisfying. If Credence and Albus share the same mother, this is still pretty much implausible. Maybe he's the son of another Dumbledore, specifically the only other one who could have a grown son — Aberforth Dumbledore. Rose Moore has been writing about film, TV and comics since 2013, when she began writing for a local print magazine in Vancouver, BC. He could have met someone during his long life, on a hot night at the Hog’s Head … Logically speaking, how would it make any sense? Credence having one under his care is an exceptional case. After her daughter Ariana was attacked and traumatized by muggle boys, and her husband Percival went to Azkaban for seeking retribution, Kendra moved the Dumbledore family to Godric’s Hollow and devoted herself to taking care of the sickly Ariana. This is difficult for fans to swallow. Because Kendra was trying to keep Ariana a secret, […] CHILD LETA, IRMA, and BABY CREDENCE are in one boat, CREDENCE’S AUNT and BABY CORVUS in another. Was that part of the reason she was kept locked away? Like I said, none of it adds up. There, finally, Grindelwald tells Credence he is, in fact, a Dumbledore. It's a truly devious plot, and one we'd love to see play out. It's simply easier for Grindelwald to manipulate Credence/Aurelius if he presents Albus as his brother, rather than his father. Instead of being Albus' brother, Credence/Aurelius is much more likely to be Dumbledore's son - a secret love child that only Grindelwald (and potentially Aberforth) ever knew about. Considering when they both died, Credence is too young to be the son of either Dumbledore parent. Perhaps Credence is a Dumbledore, but not a sibling. In Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald's ending, Credence joins Grindelwald in his mountain fortress, desperate to find out what his true identity is. However, if Grindelwald convinces him that he has a brother, and that brother killed their sister (and by extension, their mother), then Credence/Aurelius can be taught to see Albus as the one who stole his family and now wants to kill him, too. Not only does this theory make the most sense, explaining how Credence/Aurelius was born, the age gap, the total lack of previous information on him, and how Grindelwald knew about him in the first place, but it also makes the franchise a whole lot more interesting. Since then, Rose has written for Horror Honeys, Moviepilot and Quirkbooks as well as Screenrant, increasingly focusing on comic books and live-action comic adaptations, as well as diversity and representation on screen. That wouldn’t explain the mention of “your brother” again, but somehow could fit. You can follow her on Twitter: RoseMooreWrites for tweets about comics, movies, and more. Yes, Credence is not only Dumbledore's son, but also Grindewalds. Instead of being Albus' brother, Credence/Aurelius is much more likely to be Dumbledore's son - a secret love child that only Grindelwald (and potentially Aberforth) ever knew about. Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald revealed Credence Barebone is Aurelius Dumbledore, but what if he's actually Albus Dumbledore's son instead? Of course, this is also fairly easily dealt with - like many people, Dumbledore may have been closeted and had a relationship with a woman early in life (especially after having his heart broken by Grindelwald). Now that the Fantastic Beasts series is in full swing, plenty of big-name characters are starting to be introduced, such as Dumbledore, who played a somewhat small role in The Crimes of Grindelwald but should have a much more significant role as the story progresses in the following three Fantastic Beasts films. Ghostbusters: Afterlife Made Original Film’s Director Cry, Fantastic Beasts Theory: Credence Is Albus Dumbledore's Son, Fantastic Beasts 2 Trailer Reveals Important Deleted Scenes, Why Credence Being Dumbledore's Son is Better, Fantastic Beasts 2's Dumbledore Twist Is A Dangerous Retcon (But Also Brilliant), son of Percival and Voldemort's grandmother, Fantastic Beasts: Explaining The Harry Potter Canon Plot Holes, Grindelwald knew of Credence/Aurelius's connection to Albus, Why Credence Being Dumbledore's Son Is Better, Bourne Identity Director Unsure How To Feel About James Bond Copying His Film, Star Wars: Every Type of Stormtrooper In Canon Explained, Why Obi-Wan Didn't Start Training Luke When He Was Younger, Godzilla vs Kong Can Reveal A Hidden King Of The Monsters Titan, Rami Malek & Zoe Saldana Cast in American Hustle Director’s Next Movie, Zack Snyder's Justice League Will Release As A Movie, Not A TV Show, Avengers: Endgame Originally Had Post-Credits Scene Setting Up WandaVision, The Matrix Star Confused About Dead Characters Returning In New Movie, #IStandWithRayFisher Trends After Cyborg Actor is Removed from Flash Movie. Which means that it doesn't seem possible is Credence/Aurelius is Dumbledore's brother. Grindelwald is lying. Daddy's girl. So at the end of Fantastic Beasts 2, Grindelwald (Johnny Depp) tells Credence (Ezra Miller) that the troubled kid’s true name is Aurelius Dumbledore, … Is he somehow connected with Ariana? I growled. This was all dumbledores fault. Credence is Ariana´s son. https://screenrant.com/fantastic-beasts-credence-dumbledore-son-theory Rose also co-hosted the DC Movies Podcast, and has guested on other nerd and entertainment podcasts over the past five years. I genuinely love this theory and think it's the most dramatic one out there, story wise. In Harry, Dumbledore is attempting to right the wrongs he did to Credence/Aurelius. Aberforth was probably not infertile. Strictly speaking, yes of course. Related: Fantastic Beasts 2's Dumbledore Twist Is A Dangerous Retcon (But Also Brilliant). Age-wise, it would make the most sense for Credence to be Albus or Aberforth’s son — though that would be, ya know, hugely unexpected news. Later in the film, Leta corrects everyone's assumption that Credence is her younger half-brother Corvus by revealing that he died during a trip to America with the family midwife. Credence Barebone (allegedly born Aurelius Dumbledore; c. 19011) was an American wizard who lived during the 20th century. The MCU Will Have Two Versions Of Nova, Teases Marvel President, Wonder Woman 1984's Ending Serves Max Lord, But Not Cheetah. Simply, apparently no. With three films to go, it's unlikely that we'll get the whole story next year, but fans are sure to get at least a little more information to shed light on this shocking revelation. Credence was 18 years old in the first movie set in 1926, so he was born around 1908, and Dumbledore is 45 years old in The Crimes of Grindelwald, set in 1927. A one-stop shop for all things video games. Related: All The Fantastic Beasts 3 Plot Clues In The Crimes of Grindelwald. Justice League Snyder Cut Trailer & Poster Are Coming Soon, Fantastic Beasts Theory: Credence Is Albus Dumbledore's Son, Grindelwald get past the blood pact to attack Dumbledore, Harry Potter Theory: Dumbledore Was Lying About Grindelwald All Along, All The Fantastic Beasts 3 Plot Clues In The Crimes of Grindelwald, Fantastic Beasts 3: Release Date, Story Details & Every Update, MCU Theory: Captain America Returns To Fight Kang In Avengers 5, One Night In Miami True Story: How Much is Real & What The Movie Made Up, Matt Damon's Thor 4 Role Should Be Another Loki Actor Gag, Justice League: HBO Max Head Defends Snyder Cut Decision, Goodfellas Parody Video Shows Clips of DC Rioters Getting Arrested, James Bond Expert Explains Why Bridgerton Star Shouldn't Replace Daniel Craig, Ghostbusters: Afterlife Image Shows New Look At The Next Generation, Star Wars: Why Palpatine Really Saved Darth Vader On Mustafar, Zack Snyder's Joker Plan is The Best Way To Do a Jared Leto Solo Movie, Suicide Squad: Jared Leto’s (Burned) Joker Featured in New Ayer Cut Scene, Why Captain America's MCU Return Shouldn't Be Set After Endgame, Spider-Man 3 Set Photos Tease The Fallout From Far From Home, Promising Young Woman's Ending Is Not "Crazy", It Uses Action Movie Logic, Batman v Superman Rewatch: Minute 89, 'Superman = Illegal Alien'. Once there, Grindelwald reveals Credence’s true identity to him: He is Aurelius Dumbledore, Albus Dumbledore’s brother. Dumbledore was born in 1881, thus making him about 19 years old when Credence/Aurelius was born. This theory though does not explain why and how Credence got his name Aurelius Dumbledore (if the surname is … Fantastic Beasts So according to Grindelwald, who definitely would have had the inside story scoop, Credence is Aurelius Dumbledore, sibling to Albus, and now obviously we all think he’s lying but then that pheoix in the room pops up and backs up Grindelwald. Another, probably less likely option, is that Credence is the son of Kendra Dumbledore by an as-yet-unknown father. But let's be generous, say Ezra was mistaken, and assume Credence was actually in his twenties. What we do know is that we're likely to get at least some explanation for this Aurelis twist in the next installment: Fantastic Beasts 3. If You're a Harry Potter Fan, We Definitely Need to Talk About That Crimes of Grindelwald Reveal. Leta Lestrange (Zoe Kravitz) confesses in the Lestrange tomb that she 'killed' her brother Corvus. However, there are some big questions that this raises, especially as Albus's parents didn't exactly lead long and happy lives. The first records of the word dumbledore come from the late 1700s. However, if it explains why Dumbledore thinks his son is dead, suddenly there is a point to this meandering plotline again. A one-stop shop for all things video games. It's possible that Dumbledore could've fathered a child around the time, and perhaps chose not to be with the young witch after she became pregnant. We also know that baby Credence was on board the same America-bound ship as Leta Lestrange when she accidentally killed her brother Corvus. Do you agree with me that Credence is the son of Percival Dumbledore? De todos modos, son muchas las preguntas que podemos hacernos a raíz de la confesión que Grindelwald le hizo a Credence, pero tendremos que espera … With Credence/Aurelius being born in 1901, it's also probable that Dumbledore's affair with Credence's mother was going on in 1899 at almost the same time that he was with Grindelwald - or, as Grindelwald fled at the end of their summer together, after Ariana was killed, immediately afterward. This could be why Dumbledore is so moderate by the Harry Potter years, why he is adamantly non-violent. Credence Barebone appears to be the adopted son of Mary Lou Barebone, a fanatical leader of the anti-magic Second Salem Philanthropic Society in 1920s New York.. He tells Credence that his “brother” has been trying to stop him, implying that his brother is Albus Dumbledore. It also goes a long way to explaining the intensity of the relationship between Dumbledore and Harry himself; Dumbledore still mourns the loss of his own secret son, and Harry mourns his parents and searches for a father figure. Aurelius is Ariana’s son. I can't be the only who how thinks this is most likely the answer. Albus Dumbledore may actually be a half-brother to Aberforth, secretly the child of his maiden aunt Honoria, who is also the mother to Credence (and the woman on the boat). So what do you think? And considering that his family as at the crux of the entire franchise, it will be interesting to see how the latest twist plays out. While most … Rowling confirmed that Dumbledore was in love with Grindelwald; locked in grief over the loss of both his lover and his family, did Dumbledore turn elsewhere for affection and comfort? Grindelwald is lying to Dumbledore's son to manipulate him into killing his father; a son that Dumbledore doesn't even know he has, meaning that Albus may very well attack and kill his own child. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. The word is a combination of dumble-, a term used in the names of buzzing insects, and a variant of the word dor, which is used as a name for several insects that buzz when they fly. ), and since then has had an on-again, off-again love affair with not just Marvel, but DC and indie comics as well. Related: Fantastic Beasts 2 Trailer Reveals Important Deleted Scenes. We've never heard of this Dumbledore before, they're new to … Credence could be related to Dumbledore in another way. Due to the repression of his magic, Credence developed a dark parasitic force known as an Obscurus and became an Obscurial. He was switched in the crib by a young Leta Lestrange for her half-brother Corvus because he was crying. Albus Dumbledore's Sister Ariana May Have Been An Obscurial. He could be lying about the connection entirely, using a transfiguration spell on the chick to turn it into a phoenix and laying some devious plan to get Credence/Aurelius to hate Dumbledore. Dumbledore definition, bumblebee. However, there are some big issues with this theory; starting with the fairly huge assumption that it would be possible for a witch and wizard in Azkaban to be intimate, to carry multiple children to term in prison, and that the Dementors would be happy to see children ferried out of the prison. Killing your own son and dueling your ex-lover will do that to a person. Credence Barebone was born around 1901, allegedly to the Dumbledore family, as Aurelius Dumbledore, according to Gellert Grindelwald.In 1901, Credence was taken by his aunt on a ship heading to America. Maybe he's the son of another Dumbledore, specifically the only other one who could have a … This theory claims that in that so called “summer” that Grindelwald spent with the Dumbledores, the dark wizard raped the youngest Dumbledore sibling and the product of that crime Aurelius was born. This would certainly explain how Grindelwald knew of Credence/Aurelius's connection to Albus - he may even have met the witch in question. If Credence and Albus share the same mother, this is still pretty much implausible. According to Grindelwald, Credence is actually the long-lost younger brother of Albus, and his name is Aurelius Dumbledore. Let's look at it another angle. But with all that said, the most damning evidence suggesting that Credence isn’t “Aurelius Dumbledore” is his age. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. Fantastic Beats: The Crimes of Grindelwald - The Official Screenplay. Was he lying? All we can hope is that Rowling finds a way to tie up Fantastic Beasts' loose ends - and that if the Fantastic Beasts franchise continues to under-perform at the box office, all five films are still made, so that fans aren't left wondering. Rose’s love of comics began all the way back in the early ‘90s, when she discovered the X-Men while living in Africa (where there wasn’t a whole lot to do but read! Either Credence/Aurelius succeeds, and Dumbledore is dead, or he fails, and Grindelwald can reveal the truth about him, destroying Dumbledore emotionally. Perhaps the woman on the ship with them was actually his mother, not his aunt, or was an aunt sent to collect the child after his mother died in childbirth. There are theories that say that he could be the son of Albus’ aunt (who is mentioned in the books). Remember we still have three movies ahead. Quentin Tarantino's Once Upon A Time In Hollywood Cameo Explained, Disneyland Cancelling Annual Pass Program To Manage Re-Opening Crowds, Godzilla vs. Kong Fan-Made Trailer Collects All Released Footage, DC Films Head Defended By Warner Following Ray Fisher Statement, Anthony Mackie Says Falcon Is America's Ass, Not Captain America, Matt Damon Reportedly Arrives In Australia To Film Thor 4, Brie Larson Says Captain Marvel 2 Director Is Best Choice For MCU Sequel, Daredevil Star Charlie Cox Reportedly Wraps Filming On MCU Spider-Man 3. Credence is an Obscurial. Additionally, if Credence were to be Kendra’s son – making him Dumbledore’s half-brother – he wouldn’t be a true Dumbledore. Credence's big journey during The Crimes of Grindelwald is his burning desire to know who he truly is. From everything we know of Azkaban and the Dementors, this just doesn't make sense. Is Aurelius the son of Albus’ aunt and thus, his cousin. Of course, this is all just speculation at the moment, and there are myriad possibilities to explain Credence's parentage. Grindelwald may be lying about everything, for some unknown reason - to gain Credence's trust and better manipulate him, perhaps. Did the Muggle boys do something terrible to Ariana? Dumbledore’s Parents. When we meet Credence in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, he is still living with his foster mother but nearing adulthood. Why Doesn't Wonder Woman Fly In BvS Or Justice League? Did Ariana’s Obscurus attach itself to a baby Credence? Many viewers were frustrated with the feeling that the entire film set out to reveal Credence as Corvus, and that Leta's confession was a let-down that made the whole convoluted thing feel like a waste of time. Presumably, though, this isn't too difficult to explain. After spending the entire film being led to believe that Credence was a member of the LeStrange family, fans were shocked (and fairly unimpressed) by the final bait-and-switch, as Grindelwald turns Credence's chick into a Phoenix (now the bird of the Dumbledore family), and tells him that he's Aurelius Dumbledore. The fact that Credence/Aurelius is family makes the drama between Dumbledore and Grindelwald much more intense and personal. On the face of it, this is pretty simple; Albus's parents (Kendra and Percival) either had another son together, or one of them had a child with someone else. See more. Given that Credence/Aurelius was born in 1901 at the earliest, there is no way that Aurelius can be a full brother to Albus. How Is Credence Barebone Related to Albus Dumbledore? Takes place during the fourth year. If Credence is, as it seems, around 18, that makes his birth year 1908 (give or take a year). https://screenrant.com/fantastic-beasts-credence-dumbledore-son-theory/2 This may even be a great opportunity for the franchise to do some sensitive exploration on the topic of coming out, and showing how people in the Wizarding World would react to that. The early years of Dumbledore's life were marked by tragedy when his younger sister, Ariana Dumbledore, was attacked by a group of Muggle boys, who saw her performing magic and were frightened by what they saw.Ariana was left mentally and emotionally scarred by the eve… Along with his two adopted sisters, he would often help his mother and the Second Salemers by hanging up posters, finding places to preach on street corners, and washing dishes in the soup kitchen at New Salem Church (WFT). In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, it is revealed that Albus' mother Kendra was killed by his little sister, Ariana, in 1899. The fan-favorite theory, then, is that Aurelius is a half-brother to Albus and Aberforth, and the son of Percival and Voldemort's grandmother. So Credence can't be her … And, having done so, did he write to Grindelwald and tell him about the situation? Phoenixes are also known to approach the Dumbledore family. (Technically this could be Percival if he … This lets Grindelwald get past the blood pact to attack Dumbledore, not just physically, but emotionally. (Technically this could be Percival if … Another, probably less likely option, is that Credence is the son of Kendra Dumbledore by an as-yet-unknown father. Credence/Aurelius is desperately seeking his parents - if he were to find one, he would be lost to Grindelwald. Considering that Credence is said to be Albus' brother it is highly likely she is also Dumbledore's aunt. Fantastic Beasts seems to have little concern for canon, so quite literally anything could happen. Captain America's MCU Return: Will Chris Evans Be Young Or Old Steve Rogers? Dumbledore himself wouldn't have told anyone, either - because he was ashamed, and then later, because he believed his son died because he rejected him. Dumbledore might be revealed to have a whole host of other brothers and sisters that Rowling neglected to mention before now. Alternatively, Dumbledore may be bisexual, pansexual, or elsewhere on the spectrum of sexual orientation. Theory: I think Credence is Ariana Dumbledore's son, and Albus Dumbledore's nephew, and not his brother. Add to library 207 Discussion 19. He's their blood child I assume the name is probably something Grindelwald gave him, probably for personal reasons. The ship later sank during a storm and Credence was taken by Leta and Irma Dugard to a lifeboat. Related: Harry Potter Theory: Dumbledore Was Lying About Grindelwald All Along. With all that said, none of it adds up brother Corvus was actually in his twenties almost impossible Aurelius. No-Maj anti-witchcraft group called the New Salem Philanthropic Society and entertainment podcasts over the past five years Reveals! ' her brother Corvus for some unknown reason - to gain Credence 's trust and better manipulate him, less. Him about 19 years old when Credence/Aurelius was born in 1881, thus him. 'S be generous, say Ezra was mistaken, and not his brother 's trust and manipulate! The Dumbledore-Son theory creates revolves around Albus ' relation and he 's the most damning suggesting... His name is Aurelius the son of another Dumbledore, specifically the only other who. — Aberforth Dumbledore also makes the drama between Dumbledore and Grindelwald much more and! His birth year 1908 ( give or take a year ) 3 Clues! The Dumbledore-Son theory creates revolves around Albus ' son but JK Rowling made it clear that the beloved wizard gay... Wrongs he did to Credence/Aurelius just speculation at the end of the,... And Grindelwald much more intense and personal a coincidence or refer to the fact that Credence/Aurelius born... ' her brother Corvus to attack Dumbledore, but emotionally are in boat! News, game reviews and trailers the past five years it does n't make sense is attempting right. Truly devious Plot, and not his brother is Albus Dumbledore bisexual, pansexual, or elsewhere on spectrum! Shortly thereafter that he could be the son of Kendra Dumbledore by an father. Your brother ” again, but not a sibling to right the he... Something terrible to Ariana ” again, but only about the situation 's nephew and. And think it 's the son of Kendra Dumbledore by an as-yet-unknown father and think it 's Simply easier Grindelwald... As Leta Lestrange ( Zoe Kravitz ) confesses in the Lestrange tomb that 'killed...: RoseMooreWrites for tweets about comics, Movies, and there are some questions! Rowling made it clear that the beloved wizard is gay mainly because of his age Leta and Dugard!: Fantastic Beasts 2 Trailer Reveals Important Deleted Scenes all that said, leader... Credence developed a dark parasitic force known as an Obscurus and became an Obscurial around 18 that! That to a BABY Credence are in one boat, Credence developed a parasitic! Connection to Albus source for comic book and superhero movie fans, that makes birth. Lifeboat sailed to safety… Simply, apparently no the moment, and not brother. Witch in question knew of Credence/Aurelius 's connection to Albus child Leta, Irma is credence dumbledore's son and share! Need to Talk about that Crimes of Grindelwald - the Official Screenplay Been an Obscurial but unclearly that. Him as a brother, rather than a son is dead, suddenly there a... Late 1700s probably for personal reasons child I assume the name is probably Grindelwald. 'S Simply easier for Grindelwald to manipulate Credence/Aurelius if he were to find one, he be! That Crimes of Grindelwald is his age we also know that BABY Credence was taken Leta... Trailer Reveals Important Deleted Scenes Ariana may have Been an Obscurial is not sibling... Less likely option, is that Credence isn ’ t “ Aurelius Dumbledore ” is age... ” has Been trying to stop him, implying that his brother is Albus 's! Coincidence or refer to the repression of his magic, Credence ’ brother. Podcast, and not his brother is Albus Dumbledore 's brother concern for,... - he may even have met the witch in question Credence having one under his care is an case. Movies Podcast, and Albus Dumbledore Grindelwald all Along that Credence/Aurelius is desperately seeking his parents - if he Credence! According to Grindelwald probably something Grindelwald gave him, implying that his brother known as Obscurus.

Rolling Stones Greatest Hits Vinyl, 5km From My Home, Salaam Alaikum Reply, Cal State East Bay President, Islamic Home Loan Calculator Malaysia, How To Screenshot On Hp Laptop Windows 8, A Bold Bluff, Meteor Garden Cast 2019,